I have seen a great rise in the number of churches that turn the lights off in the sanctuary during corporate worship, while keeping strong lighting on the worship leaders. I have been shocked to see that this practice is now also being adopted by many older, established churches. This practice, I believe, is unhealthy biblically and in the perception that it creates. Let’s go deeper.

The practice of turning out the lights in the sanctuary during corporate worship, I believe, is unhealthy biblically, creates a spectator mindset and misaligns the purpose of worship leaders.

 

IT CREATES A SPECTATOR MINDSET IN WORSHIP

In churches that are following this practice, lights are so dim in the congregation that people may not be aware of fellow worshippers throughout the room. Following this plan leads to a true sense that the “audience” has come to a performance, and thus they stand and do not participate. Throughout culture, we have come to realize that when we enter an auditorium with a brightly-lit stage and lights that are out in the auditorium, we are to sit and watch the performance unfolding on the stage (concert, theater, etc.). This tends to breed a spectator role in the congregants, keeping them from fully participating in the songs, readings, etc. In fact, many churches are keeping the lights really low or off during the sermon, denying those who want to read from their Bibles the opportunity unless they bring a book light with them.

IT DENIES A BIBLICAL MANDATE FOR CORPORATE WORSHIP

Perhaps even more noteworthy to this argument is the biblical imperative that worship should be vertical (congregation to God) and horizontal (congregant to congregant) in nature:

Speak to one another with psalms, hymns and spiritual songs. Sing and make music in your heart to the Lord, always giving thanks to God the Father for everything, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. (Ephesians 5:19–20).

This passage brings up an important point that is vastly overlooked today. Gathered worship has a horizontal and a vertical element. Not only is our worship directed to God as we offer Him our praise and worship, giving thanks for all He has done. It also requires us to “speak to one another” in declaring His worth, testifying of His goodness, etc. Gathered worship has a communal aspect that differentiates it from personal worship. In addition, I have found that experiencing the people around me in worship can encourage me to worship more wholeheartedly. It is moving to come to worship and see a family present that has just lost a loved one, and see them worshipping with all their might; it really encourages those around them. Seeing a grandmother, daughter, and granddaughter standing side by side, boldly singing songs to the Lord together, motivates others to worship wholeheartedly. The communal aspect of corporate worship cannot be understated. It is vital to our lives to have that interaction in worship.

IT MISALIGNS THE TRUE PURPOSE OF WORSHIP LEADERS

Another great concern I have is tied to the role of worship leaders. Those of us entrusted to lead the congregation in worship need to see and hear the people we are leading as we take them on the journey of worship. When the light differential between the stage and the auditorium is too great, worship leaders cannot see the people they are leading. The role of worship leaders is not to be performers, but rather to guide the journey as servants who do all we can to aid the congregation in voicing their praise and worship. (To go deeper with this understanding, check out the book, The Worship Ministry Guidebook.)

Too often, in many instances of “contemporary worship,” churches transform their times of gathered worship into personal worship for the congregation at best and spectatorship at worst by turning the lights down, so you don’t see anyone around you. Essentially, it denies the existence of the corporate body journeying together in this act of worship when you cannot see your fellow worshippers. There have been times I have had congregations turn and face each other as they sing a song of testimony, declaring the worth of God to each other to help them recognize that we are in this together. We can exhort, encourage, comfort, and so much more in the gathered, horizontal aspect of worship.

SO DOES OUR LIGHTING NEED TO BE AT 100%?

No. There is an argument to be made that dimmer lighting can encourage people to have more freedom in worship. Just make sure you meet two requirements to offset the the issues outlined above:

  1. Make sure the lighting is bright enough for people to see everyone in the room easily.
  2. Make sure the differential in the stage lighting and auditorium lighting is such that worship leaders can easily see the people they are leading.

NEXT STEPS

Too often today, worship leaders are following practices they see in other churches, thinking that is the way worship should be. It is imperative that we have a biblical understanding of worship and an understanding of the role of a worship leader. Then all of our practices, such as the songs we choose, the keys we select to sing the songs, the level of lighting and sound, the way we repeat songs, etc. will flow out of these foundations. Want to learn more? Sign up for one of our Advanced Worship Leader Training retreats, or grab a copy of The Worship Ministry Guidebook